CLOSED

                                                        Photo by matthew Feeney on Unsplash 

This site is going dark. PLEASE subscribe to https://philanthropy2173.ghost.io/  All the old posts are now there and I will no longer be double posting over here. Thanks for two great decades - see you in the new place.

A warning to #nonprofits and #foundations in the USA

 Is over here on the new site - https://philanthropy2173.ghost.io/shoulda-started-yesterday/

Please hit the subscribe button over there so I can stop double posting!

More new posts - have you moved your subscription yet?

I'm still double posting over here to get readers over to the new site. There's a new post up

https://philanthropy2173.ghost.io/have-you-had-covid/

Ghost should allow newsletter sending pretty soon - so make sure you've signed up over there as I'll stop posting here once the newsletter function goes live over there.

Philanthropy2173.ghost.io

 

Philanthropy2173.ghost.io

There's another new post on the new site:

https://philanthropy2173.ghost.io/

If you hit the subscribe button on the new site, you'll get those posts directly in your email. I'm working with the new host site to allow the posts to be sent to subscribers over here. 

Another new post over at Philanthropy2173.ghost.io

Click here to read it. 

Sign up over there to get them directly to your inbox. 

https://philanthropy2173.ghost.io/

Philanthropy2173.ghost.io

 There's a new post over at https://philanthropy2173.ghost.io/u-s-civil-society-under-attack/. 

I have to post these here for now so that the posts still go to subscribers. (I'm working on it,

I'm working on it)

https://philanthropy2173.ghost.io/u-s-civil-society-under-attack/

 

Moving the blog - philanthropy2173.ghost.io

Our tech stacks matter. It's easiest to use products made by big companies, but in the online world, doing so means you don't own your stuff, the oligarchs who own the companies own your stuff. I'm not a fan of oligarchs. I've been blogging for more than 20+ years and have moved this site a few times. And the time has come to move it again. 

                                                                            Illustration by Tom Worth, in Blueprint 2025

It's going over here - philanthropy2173.ghost.io

If you subscribed to the blog, you're subscribed over there. If you're reading this on LinkedIN, please subscribe directly at philanthropy2173.ghost.io

.

It will take me some time to migrate everything over, so I'll be holding on to the blogger site for awhile. But not for long - paying for two sites ain't cheap. Getting the .ghost.io off the blog name costs even more, bear with me, please.

Reading through a new lens

Zuckerberg, Musk, and Bezos are paying for and hosting parties for the incoming. Don't get worked up about that - you're not invited.

DO get worked up about the fact that, starting a few weeks ago, you should NOT trust any information you see on Facebook, Instagram, or WhatsApp. Why? Because Mark owns them. He has been telling you for weeks he's going to deliberately flood the first (Facebook) with AI people and end all content moderation. In this way, Facebook can "help" the #Trusk administration to incarcerate and deport people with brown skin.* Methinks this is what Mark speaks of when he seeks "more masculine energy."

It also makes it easier for people with the very whitest skin to steal from the government (NASA contracts sole-sourced to X, medicare billing overseen by Oz, lord only knows how deep Trump's own grift goes). Stealing from the government BY THE WAY is stealing from you - you paid your taxes. Those three guys at the top of this blog - not so much. 

People, nonprofits and foundations still working for anything other than an oligarchic agenda, people still pursuing communities built on care and participation - ASSUME what you're reading online is BULLSHIT. Designed to distract and detract. I cannot say this any more clearly. The first item on their agenda - minimize, confuse, deflect, and diminish the administration's plan for internment camps and deportations.

 

                                                                Illustration by Tom Worth from Blueprint2025

And since Bezos has also bent the knee - enough to hang out with his sworn frenemy Musk - it's well past time to check where your "cloud" storage actually lives. Chances are better than 75% its on Bezos's servers. It's either there or on Google/Microsoft's servers. It's probably on all three, and add in Zoom. Can you possibly afford to host your own cloud? If so, do it. Yesterday. 

TL;DR

• Check your tech stack and get off their servers. (Yes, I know this blog is hosted by Google - changing platforms is hard - help in doing so appreciated - DM me).
  
• Assume what you're reading online is BS. Coming from bots, malevolent actors, and/or AI.
  
• Figure out how to communicate truth online (or rebuild your comms function, because you don't need a lot of social media followers (ahem - who owns them? - see above), you need to tell the truth)

Prediction from a non-predictor: In 2025 a progressive nonprofit, probably a Muslim-focused one, will find itself being persecuted by the US Federal Government, and the government will use internal messages, blog posts, socialmedia posts, zoom and Otter AI transcripts and information from internal documents stored on the cloud or AI-transcribed zoom calls as "evidence." No, they won't get warrants or even notify you that they're doing this - after all, your stuff is on their property. Assume you will be next (don't quote Heschel to me).

One of two US voters chose this. If you're one of them, and still reading my stuff, know that I hold you responsible for all of the horrors to come. Happy to chat with you but know that I believe your only absolution (which I don't control) is working to rectify things for those who are being immediately and directly hurt by your desire to save on taxes (and, no, egg prices won't go down. There's a bird flu now circulating among humans, c'mon on, now).

*I am a disabled, queer, Jew. No, I don't want to be called crip, faggot, or hebe online. But this IS NOT why they're doing what they're doing. They're doing it to (further) poison the well of news. That's the fight we need to be fighting. They're closely linked, but let's be clear on their purpose and their endgame. 

Blueprint 2025!

#Blueprint 2025 is here 

Join us to discuss tomorrow January 16, 2025.

My health is poor, and so the planning for future Blueprints (or whatever comes next) is in your hands. Help me work with you to co-create our collective next. The short survey is in the #Blueprint and here's a direct link to be part of it.

Philanthropy book club

                                                            Photo by rawkkim on unsplash

There is so much uncertainty in my life right now. I've spent a lifetime reading fiction for joy and mental health, and reading nonfiction for work and an income (OK, I read some nonfiction for fun) and I've always read alone. My sister and I, in the early days of online life, launched a book review that we used to print and distribute at the cash registers of independent book stores in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Baltimore and San Francisco. In just the last year, however, as my illness has made me more and more isolated, I've joined one book club, started another, and am now suggesting a third. 

If you'd like to join a zoom-based reading group focused on books about #philanthropy and #civil society than please let me know by commenting here, DM'ing me on Bluesky or Mastodon, emailing me, or filling out this form. Let me know your name, one book you'd want to read, email, and what time zone you're in. We already have participants from India and California, so we'll be choosing globally accessible times as best we can. I'm hopeful we'll get readers and book suggestions from around the world. (Books need to be written in English language or translations into English, nonfiction and fiction welcome)

My suggested book is Dana Frank's new history of the Great Depression, What Can We Learn From the Great Depression? Stories of Ordinary People and Collective Action in Hard Times, which focuses on the role of community leaders, mutual aid, and other forms of solidarity. I don't know Professor Frank personally, but she's right down the road in my old stomping grounds of Santa Cruz and I may be able to invite her to join when we get to that book. 

At least one of my Stanford colleagues, Aaron Horvath, says he'll join me in this. Aaron is one of the co-leaders of a new project on Private Wealth and the Public Good, and a longtime participant in and teacher of the Stanford PACS seminar. I'm no longer able to teach the Stanford seminar on Digital Civil Society so I'm hopeful this might scratch my "go to seminar" itch. All that being said, participants will be asked to lead the conversation on the book they suggest so no goofing off allowed. There will be no quizzes.

Will try to get this going in February.

100 years too early

The 2173 in the name of this blog refers to the year, 2173. The year was 200 years in the future from 1973, when the futurist comedy "Sleeper"was made. 

Turns out, it's 100 years too late. There's a movie out (coming out) called 2073 that uses real-life footage from today's news to tell a story of a future apocalyptic hellscape. It caught my attention because of the title and because I'd been outlining a piece of fiction using the same primary sources.

Wikipedia says:

"2073 is a 2024 British science fiction docudrama film directed by Asif Kapadia. Set in a dystopian future, the film is inspired by Chris Marker's 1962 featurette La Jetée. It follows a time traveller who risks his life to change the course of history and save the future of humanity.

The documentary premiered out of competition at the 81st Venice International Film Festival on 3 September 2024.^"

You're welcome. Maybe 2173 will be when things turn again from the bleakness to something good.

In Authoritarian America, first, they came for Wikipedia and the Wayback Machine

It's amazing to me, that a time when the nonprofit and philanthropic sector in the USA should be running around screaming "house on fire" (very bad metaphor for a Californian), most seem to to be just plodding along. I am hopeful that they're being digitally savvy; shifting to encrypted platforms, scrubbing their websites of information that will enable doxxing of volunteers, constituents, staff and boar; red-teaming their governance policies and crossing every T; dotting every i on their financial statements; meeting with lawyers; raising funds for legal defense.  

                                                Photo by Dalton Abraham, Unsplash

They must not only worry about the official US government under Trusk. Worry about #KingMusk himself. And his minions. And his berserk followers. And his allies in the Russian and Chinese hacking communities. Want to know what harassment of your organization might look like? Look at what's happening with Wikipedia/Wikimedia Foundation. 

The Heritage Foundation (home to Project Esther and Project 2025) is preparing to use facial recognition and online sources to dox contributors to Wikipedia. They claim this has something to do with antisemitism. BS. They'll go after Jewish and Palestinian issues first but they're really trying to take down THE site that the global public turns to when disaster, war, corruption strike. They've also gone after The Internet Archive, home to the Wayback Machine, which is the oft-cited "backup" of the internet. Lawsuits are one strategy (see Internet Archive). Doxxing and harassment are another strategy (See Heritage and Wikimedia)

Public Citizen has been on the offensive, opposing OpenAI's efforts to abandon its nonprofit status without returning to the public the value of its tax exempt status to date (an estimated $30 Billion). Thank goodness for that, because letting tech entrepreneurs have free rein over the nonprofit tax exemption is a nightmare I'd rather not consider. 

But what about suing Heritage for violating tax laws or reckless endangerment? What about pulling the old trick that I love watching backfire on Texas - pass a law banning sexual content in books in schools, only to discover you must now remove the Bible. With the low quality of expected appointees to places like the IRS, the FTC, and the FEC, smart lawyers on the center - left ought to be able to find gaps in their legislation big enough to drive a truck (or the Heritage Foundation itself) through. 

What about offense? 48.3 percent of voters didn't vote for this coming nightmare. Basically 1 in 2 of us. Rally us. Mobilize us. Listen to us, we are civil society.

The #Blueprint Series - (#16 launches on January 15 - get your free copy here) - has been tracking, commenting on, jumping up and down about the steady deliberate corruption of democratic norms undertaken by the #GOP for the last decade and a half, preceding even the Citizens United debacle. I can only hope people have read it and responded by taking their digital security (and physical security of volunteers, staff, boards, and constituents) seriously. Partnering with similar organizations to build a legal defense fund. Getting good legal advice. Workshopping messages about the importance of a diverse, pluralistic, fragmented and abundant nonprofit sector (What we have at the start of 2025. Who knows what will be left by 2028). 

Donors and philanthropists - you're not safe in this, so don't sit back and watch. Foundations will be interrogated. Donors will be doxxed. Some philanthropists will cave, if they haven't already while wearing their CEO hat (see Bezos, Zuckerberg, etc.). Some will be targeted and made boogeyman in ways worse than the decades of lies the GOP has trafficked about George Soros. Women donors and networks? I'd expect little good and lots of bad from the misogynists-in-chief.

The Democracy Funders Network is out with some more preparatory guidelines - access those here. 

Both Wikimedia and the Internet Archive are well-established, cornerstone organizations of civil society. They were at the forefront of our collective conversion to digital civil society. We need both of them to survive.

And so it begins

Remember this post - from a few days ago - about how I was marking a baseline for free speech in the USA? 

I'm still speaking my mind, but looks like the mainstream press is having a tougher time. Several senior editors and reporters have left the Washington Post, including political cartoonist Ann Telnaes, who resigned when King Bezos's minions killed her cartoon about supplicant tech execs. 

Below is the cartoon the paper chose not to run:

 

(c) Copyright Ann Telnaes

 

First they kill cartoons, then they kill stories on the EPIC corruption we can expect from this White House and it's actual - though by no means elected - chief decision maker, #EmperorMusk. 

 

As I've said repeatedly over the years, the nonproift sector in the USA has much to learn from the past two decades of the hollowed out journalism industry.  It also has much to fear from the press's capitulation to POTUS and his tempermental vindictiveness.

It's not just the WashPost. Did you read in the paper about the manifesto written by the guy (US born, white) who blew up a cybertruck in front of a Trump Hotel? No, you didn't. Because, as is being reported now that the story has moved off the front pages, the guy was a big fan of #KingMusk, the president-elect, and RFK, Jr. Domestic terrorism by "their" guys, apparently, is not the kind of news they want being told.

                                                           Image accessed on Reddit

But that part got left out of a lot of news coverage, pretty much all of it. 

The U.S. press has already caved to the incoming administration. I have long subscribed to The Guardian, and am now also following several Canadian, Australian, and South African papers online. If I could read another language besides English well enough to follow the news, I'd draw from other places as well. 

What on earth does this have to do with philanthropy? Have you donated* to a nonprofit news site that you depend on? If in the USA, are you ready to protect PBS and NPR? Because once they destroy the independence of the media, they can commence the greatest grift ever attempted - the #billionaire suck on the U.S. federal government teat.

*If any of you philanthropy insiders are aware of a legal defense fund for these news sites, I'd love to know about it. If you are donating** to such a site, give a little more if you can - they are going to be sued by you know who.

**Despite what every piece of mail you received prior to December 31st said, that was not your last chance to donate. It was your last chance to itemize your donation on your 2024 taxes. Chances are, you don't itemize anyway. And, if you do, you can just itemize it for 2025.